Tuesday, 9 February 2010

News from Poland

INTERNATIONAL

Russia to teach Poles Polish history

21.05.2009 17:19

Katyn Forest, 1940

Russia wants to establish a revisionist committee to investigate ‘distortions of the historical record’ caused by Polish historians, informs radio Echo Moskvy. 

 

The President of the Russian Federation, Dmitry Medvedev, has signed a decree to create the Committee for the Counteraction against Attempts to Falsify History to the Detriment of Russia. “We need to free Polish, Ukrainian, Latvian and Estonian historians from the oppression of their countries’ dictatorships,” says Sergey Markov, a politician of United Russia, a  major pro-president party. 

 

Apart from Markov, the committee will consist of Russian politicians, historians, officials and secret service agents, including the head of Russian intelligence. It will investigate, they argue, distortions of the historical record caused by foreign historians as, in Markov’s opinion, “there are no such cases in Russia”. 

 

Markov claims that in Russia’s neighbouring countries, like Poland, Latvia, Ukraine and Estonia, the ruling elites are instilling an anti-Russian ideology and continue falsifying history. The newly established committee is to try and halt such attempts and “reveal historical truth”, says Markov.

 

Several disputes have occurred among Russian, Polish and other countries formerly under the influence of the Soviet Union over the historical record and Stalinist crimes. Polish historians and politicians are particularly annoyed at Moscow’s refusal to take full responsibility for the murder of over 20,000 Polish officers in the Katyn massacres of 1940, which Warsaw says amounted to attempted “genocide”. 

 

Post-Soviet governments have rejected the war crimes charges. Others in Russia still argue that the Soviets was not to blame at all and stick to the original explanation given after the graves of the officers were found during WW II that the Nazis were responsible for the deaths. (mg/pg)

Comments
  • Tadeusz Gohling 22.05.2009 00:31 Did Russia invade Hungary and Czechoslovakia?
    No according to the history of Medvedev!
    Did Russia annex one third of Polish territory?
    No, it was gifted to Russia, according to the history of Medvedev?
    Changing the countries name from USSR to Russia does not change historical facts!
    Tadeusz Gohling
  • Voj 22.05.2009 00:54 Why is this so typical of Russia? Are they serious about all this? Actually, does anyone take Russia seriously? Voj
  • Craig Ostrowski 22.05.2009 01:28 I see the Russians have not changed at all over the centuries. Their leaders niether had nor have a sense of truth an justice. They only strive for nationalism and power. I hope America & Europe will be on guard for this to protect if necessary my beloved Poland, homeland of my grandparents. Craig Ostrowski
  • Tugboat 22.05.2009 15:08 I am in full agreement with Craig, and I pray that Poland's fighting spirit is undiminished. They (as we all do to some extent) have a hard several decades coming up, being so close to the resurgent Bear. Tugboat
  • Erik S 22.05.2009 17:59 "I hope America & Europe will be on guard for this to protect if necessary my beloved Poland, homeland of my grandparents"

    What is just as bad is that the Soviets'/the communists' useful idiots in the West STILL give said Soviets/communists the benefit of the doubt:

    Check these articles from the French press:

    • Wajda's "Katyn" Is Criticized for Having the Audacity to Juxtapose the Nazis and the Soviets

    http://no-pasaran.blogspot.com/2009/04/wajda.html

    • France's Communist Daily Refers to Wajda's "Katyn" as a "Fictional" Film

    http://no-pasaran.blogspot.com/2009/04/frances-communist-daily-refers-to.html

    • La critique du Monde est prisonnière du dogme idéologique qui interdisait de mettre côte à côte les crimes d'Hitler et ceux de Staline

    http://lemondewatch.blogspot.com/2009_04_19_archive.html#8485093048665572809

    "does anyone take Russia seriously?"

    We better, because whether those 20,000 officers took the Russians seriously or not, they were soon no longer around to comment about their viewpoints…
    Erik S
  • Sam Spade 22.05.2009 19:14 The Russian attitude about fault is why they are perceived as hopeless evildoers. Sam Spade
  • stefan ratkiewicz 23.05.2009 16:14 German Russian Rhetoric

    The Germans and Russians have been historically know to become friends of convenience throughout their long history.If we travel back in time to the late 1930's before the great war started,the two belligerent countries ( Russia and Germany) were at each others throat ,politically speaking.Then to the surprise of many the propaganda exchanges suddenly ceased ,because the two states signed an extensive trade agreement.What followed was the Ribbentrop Molotov Pact and the Invasion of Polska with the plan to split the spoils amongst themselves.It is interesting to note that the French didn't intervene to assist Polska even though they had an assistance treaty in place in case of such an eventuality,it is also interesting to note that England's reply was to drop leaflets over German cities ,not quite the assistance one would expect.

    The article in Der Spiegel and the the Russian decision by President Medvedev to rehatch a sort of historical counteraction committee could very well be just rhetoric directed at Polska in order to pressure the Poles
    concerning the missile defense shield.Also this entire conundrum may be more profound than previously thought ,if one considers American hegemony in Europe and the argument of whether Nato has become a US foreign policy tool at the detriment of the European Union.Logically Nato could be replaced with a new defense organization ,the EDF European Defense Force ,but this would greatly diminish US influence over European affairs and bolster Russian confidence especially financially.Somehow the Polish Question has reemerged once again and the stakes are high for all involved,but Polska does not have to become ,as Professor Norman Davies entitled his books "God's Playground' yet again.
    stefan ratkiewicz
  • yakster 23.05.2009 21:43 It is not surprising that Russian attitude to Poland hasn't changed at all. Let's face one fact here. How may anyone expect anything but hatred from the country which has been always governed by iron hand. Without real democratic changes in Russia, there will be no change in Russian approach to Katyn issue. Given, therefore, historical evidence, Poland is entitled to seek any measures that would give this country a higher degree of security. yakster
  • Jasiek w japonii 24.05.2009 02:28 Poles themselves are first to be blamed, for they know little about the real value of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth and its philosophy. Without studying the history of the great multi-ethnic, multi-cultural democratic republic, Poles remain nothing but short-tempered old nation-state obsessed exclusive nationalist bugs that the Russians of the same sort has long been insulting and will forever. Jasiek w japonii
  • Sergey Poleshchuk 25.05.2009 12:43 Our friend Tadeusz Gohling asks: "Did Russia invade Hungary and Czechoslovakia?"

    Rather Hungary, Slovakia along with Germany invaded the Soviet union in 1941.

    Did Russia annex one third of Polish territory?
    Indeed the Soviet union annexed a part of Polish territoty along with Germany, Slovakia and Lithuania. Previously Poland along with Germany annexed parts of Czechoslovakia. Germany annexed a part of Lithuania. Hungary annexed part of Slovakia, Romania, Yugolsavia. So annexations were not something outstanding that time.

    Sergey Poleshchuk
Add new comment
name:

mail:

comment:

Published comments are the opinions of private individuals and do not reflect the views of Polskie Radio S.A. With regards to this, Polskie Radio S.A. does not accept any liability for any content published. Any comments containing vulgar language will be deleted in accordance with Polish law.
Advertise with us | Contact us

Copyright © Nowe Media, Polskie Radio S.A. All Rights Reserved