Saturday, 13 March 2010

News from Poland

INTERNATIONAL

Russia: Poland responsible for WW II

04.06.2009 13:08

 


Westerplatte, the beginning of WW II

Russian Defence Ministry has accused Poland of being responsible for World War II in an article published on its official web site. 

 

The article was written by Colonel Sergey Kovalov from the Institute of War History at the Russian Defence Ministry and published in a War Encyclopedia under the title “History – against lies and falsification”.  

 

“Everyone who studies the history of WW II without prejudice knows that the war started because Poland refused to satisfy German claims. However, not everyone knows what exactly Adolf Hitler wanted from Poland. His claims were rather moderate: to incorporate the Free City of Danzig (currently Gdansk) into the Third Reich and to let Germans build exterritorial motorway and a railway [through Poland] which would join East Prussia with the rest of German territory,” writes the Russian historian. In his opinion, “it is hard to regard these claims as unjustified”.  

 

“Poland aimed at becoming a regional super power and by no means wanted to play the role of a younger partner to Germany. That is why on 26 March 1939 it finally rejected German demands,” argues Kovalov.  

 

Russia knows better

 

The Russian historian also justifies the attack of the USSR on Poland on 17 September 1939. He claims that Josef Stalin had no choice but to sign a non-aggression pact with Hitler in order to postpone, at least in the short term, war with Germany.  

 

The Russian daily Wriemia Nowostiej has criticized the article published by the Defence Ministry, saying that “the war against falsification of history ‘to the detriment of Russia’, proclaimed by the highest state authorities, is grotesque.” 

 

The daily ironically predicts that “soon Adolf Hitler will turn out to be an effective manager and East European countries, smashed by Soviet and Nazi ‘effective management’, will be found guilty for getting in their way,” writes Wriemia Nowostiej.

 

In May, the President of the Russian Federation, Dmitry Medvedev, created the Committee for the Counteraction against Attempts to Falsify History to the Detriment of Russia. The committee consists of Russian politicians, historians, officials and secret service agents and its goal is to investigate ‘distortions of the historical record’ caused by Polish, Ukrainian, Latvian and Estonian historians. 

 

The Russian Defence Ministry’s deputy spokesman Aleksandr Petrunin refused to give thenews.pl a commentary on Kovalov’s article. (mg/pg)

 

Related stories

Russia to teach Poles Polish history

Comments
  • sRU 04.06.2009 13:47 russian is diagnosis sRU
  • doris 04.06.2009 15:18 It's incerdible! Soon all Polish people would be guilty for war and Holocaust. Very sad to read it today. doris
  • b 04.06.2009 15:33 nobody serious would take this seriously b
  • val. 04.06.2009 15:49 The russian defence ministry are a "laughing stock"
    for yet again trying to bend historical facts, as they did during comunist times. Everyone knows that Stalin was as bad, if not worse than Hitler murdering far more of his own people than the Nazis ever did.
    Medvedev, in my opinion, is just Putins puppet and Putin is running things in Rusia behind the scenes.
    The poor Rusian people have never had true democracy, so they have to put up with being dictated to by thier autocratic leaders.
    I will only ever visit Rusia when ordinary Rusians are truly free.
    val.
  • STANCZYK(MATEJKI) 04.06.2009 16:24 Just as the question "What is Truth?" was posed in a famous trial 2,000 years ago another answer could be given that "MAN YEARNS FOR THE TRUTH, WHEN FOUND, CANNOT LIVE WITH IT"......Until the "NEXT TRUTH", S STANCZYK(MATEJKI)
  • Sam Spade 04.06.2009 16:32 Kovalov is a sad example of poor education on his part. Hitler always planned to attack in the East after he secured his Western border. If the back stabber Stalin had joined Poland in 1939 to resist the Germans there might have never been a WW II. Also if the French at the same time honored their treaty with Poland like they promised to come to Poland's aid if it were attacked by Germany, the German forces would have had to fight on two fronts to their ultimate destruction.
    And Poland had no obligation to grant any corridor to Germany. It was all a pretext by Hitler to get his war and the back stabber was duped, which cost the Russian people very dearly.
    Sam Spade
  • Čech 04.06.2009 19:39 But dear mr. Kovalev wasn´t it Hitler who only wanted to annex Sudetenlands? And it happened. So why did he then annex whole Czech repulic?
    So it was same situation.
    He only want Danzig? And then...only Poznan? Only Lodz? Only Warsaw?
    Čech
  • Easy_Terran 04.06.2009 21:34 what a joke Easy_Terran
  • Jasiek 05.06.2009 00:40 It by itself is only another of usual funny Neo-Confucianist-like quibblings to call white black, but quite horrifying after you know where the essay is appearing. Moreover, there certainly are millions who live around Poland and will agree, with thunderous applause of cheap resentment, to such an argument, and that horrifies me all the more. Jasiek
  • Joe Blow 05.06.2009 03:40 If it's the official Russian stance, then it's obviously offensive, but if it's just an opinion expressed by a historian, then I think it's seemingly reasonable. Hitler indeed wanted Danzig and a corridor through the "Polish Corridor". But what this historian seems to forget that Hitler was preparing for war with Europe throughout his whole career. Whether or not Poland acquiesced, he would have attacked it. Joe Blow
Add new comment
name:

mail:

comment:

Published comments are the opinions of private individuals and do not reflect the views of Polskie Radio S.A. With regards to this, Polskie Radio S.A. does not accept any liability for any content published. Any comments containing vulgar language will be deleted in accordance with Polish law.
Advertise with us | Contact us

Copyright © Nowe Media, Polskie Radio S.A. All Rights Reserved